For today’s post I’m going to look at an exam question I saw posted on Facebook.

I confess this is the sort of stuff I get nerdy about! I love the way that equations can describe pictures, and vice versa.

Before we start, lets make sure we understand the terms used. What exactly is a ‘turning point’? Well, it is the point where the line stops going down and starts going up (see diagram below). That point at the bottom of the smile.

There are three different ways to find that but in all cases, we need to start by finding the equation – finding out the values of ‘a’ and ‘b’.

‘b’ is the easier. take the case where x=0 and the two terms with x can both be disregarded and so b = -5 = the point where the curve crosses the y-axis (also known as the line ‘X = 0’. That is similar to the reason why the term ‘c’ is often called ‘the y intercept’ for straight lines, equation y = mx+c

The other point we know is (5,0) so we can create the equation

25 + 5a – 5 = 0 (By substituting the value of 5 in for x)

We can solve this for a giving a=-4

The full equation is y = x^{2} – 4x – 5

I usually check my work at this stage 5^{2} – 4 x 5 – 5 = 0 – as required

Now, I said there were 3 ways to find the turning point. I will give all three here bu, be warned, the third does require some A-Level maths. This diary is more aimed at GCSE students but method 3 is actually the way I would usually find the turning point, so I will give a brief description here.

**Method 1 – The ‘parabola’ is symmetrical.**

A Parabola is the name of the shape formed by an x^{2} formula

On this version of the graph

I’ve marked the turning point with an X and the line of symmetry in green.

This tells us the value of x on the turning point lies halfway between the two places where y=0 (These are solutions, or roots, of x^{2} – 4x – 5 = 0

We know one of these is is x=5. We can get the other by factorising to give (x-5)(x+1) = 0. So x = -1 is the other solution. Halfway between x = -1 and x = 5 is x = 2.

when x = 2, y = 2^{2} – 4 x 2 – 5 = -9. So the turning point is (2,-9).

**Method 2 Complete the Square**

If we ‘complete the square’ on this equation we get

x^{2} – 4x + 4 – 4 – 5 – I’ve added in 4 and taken 4 away which looks like an eccentric thing to do, but this means we can factorise the first part into a square

(x – 2)^{2} – 9 (also combined the -4 and – 5 to make -9)

This where we use our knowledge that a ‘square’ is never less than 0, but it can be 0. So its minimum value is when that square = 0 – so x – 2 = , so x = 2. And we can also see the value of the whole thing there is 0 – 9 = -9

**Method 3 – By differentiation**

This is A-Level stuff really, so I’ll only give an overview. This is the way I would usually do this, but then I have studied Maths through A-level (and beyond!)

Differentiation is one branch of Calculus, the mathematics of measuring change.

By a rule you will learn if and when you first study calculus, the equation of how much x^{2} – 4x – 5 is changing is given by 2x – 4.

The turning point is where the line isn’t changing, so 2x – 4 = 0 (Zero change) so 2x = 4 and x = 2. y = 9 can be as above.

**Summary**

I’ve given three methods here. Fortunately they all give the same answer! (They wouldn’t be good alternatives otherwise!)

Choose which of the first two you feel most comfortable with. The third method is the easiest to extend to where we have equations of than an a x^{2}

I was looking back at my old GCE ‘O’ level papers (specifically paper 1 Q8 Summer 1966 Oxford board) and have a problem with a question related to finding turning point.

Given the equation C=120/V +V^2/20 the last part asks to the nearest 1/2 what is the lowest value of C.

Bearing that this question was set before calculators were invented, calculus was A level, V is present as V^-1 making it unsolvable as a quadratic (not symetrical) and it doesn’t cross C=0. I cannot see a way other than trial and error to find the answer (10.5) n.b. the rest of the question gives you/ you calculate points V= 5, 10, 11, 12, 20 which give an indication of curve shape.

Any idea how you were expected to solve? In hindsight I can’t remember whether I did this question at the time (multiple choice section of paper). I have subsequently obtained A levels and a physics degree but this has me baffled.

Sorry Brian, I don’t know how I missed this comment… I agree with you that I’d reach for calculus in the first instance but there may be a way of doing it using factorising. I may make a video about this

Hi! This helped me so much I’ve been struggling with turning points for a while and strangely enough, the A Level technique was the easiest for me (I’m at GCSE still!) Thank you so much for posting this 🙂